ESA

Harmonisation

Technology Harmonisation provides all European actors with the framework and the key instruments needed to coordinate space technology at the European level.

This is achieved by identifying the needs and existing capabilities within Europe – as documented in Technology Harmonisation Dossiers – and by agreeing on ‘European Space Technology Roadmaps’, through a process of concertation, coordination and agreement between all participants. These joint Roadmaps aim at optimising public funding and guiding developments to ensure the right technology is at the right level of maturity at the right time.

The process has been developed to achieve better-coordinated research and development activities among actors in the European space sector, establishing a strong technology base as a means of underpinning the worldwide competitiveness of European industry and ensuring the success of future space missions.

Through nearly two decades of operation, and several major reviews that recommended its strengthening, Technology Harmonisation is now an established and well-proven European process. It involves over 1,000 European takeholders, including ESA, national agencies and organisations, the European Commission, the European Defence Agency, and Space Entities (industry, R&D organisations, academia and associations).

In the scope of Harmonisation, space technologies are currently grouped into 47 topics, covering a wide range of subjects, from electric propulsion and de-orbiting technologies, to optical communications and microelectronics. Topics are continuously evolving to recognise the dynamic nature of the space sector and emerging technology trends.

Technology Coordination

Contact point
20YEARS OF HARMONISATION
47SPACE TECHNOLOGY HARMONISATION TOPICS
~10TOPICS/YEAR
30+COUNTRIES INVOLVED
1,000+EUROPEAN SPACE ENTITIES INVOLVED THROUGH OPEN CONSULTATIONS

MAIN OBJECTIVES

"Fill strategic gaps" and "Minimise unnecessary duplications"

Consolidate European Strategic Capabilities 

Achieve a Coordinated and Commited European Space technology Policy and Planning 

Contribute to continuity and coherence between technology and industrial Policies 

HOW IT WORKS

Through the Technology Coordination and Planning Office, ESA supervises and coordinates all phases of the Harmonisation process (Mapping and Roadmapping). Every year, up to 10 topics undergo Harmonisation. Therefore, topics are normally addressed and upated every about 4 years.

ESA technical experts are designated to provide the needed technical knowledge and to prepare the documentation: the Technology Harmonisation Dossiers (THD) and the Roadmaps. The final documents are available to all stakeholders via our Harmonisation Document Management System (HDMS: ht tps://tec-polaris.esa.int --> eclipse). If you do not have an account, you can request access by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company.

  • Internal coordination across ESA is achieved for technical, strategic and programmatic areas: the active participation of the Competence Domain Leads (CDL) ensures quality, coherence, relevance and consistency of the technical content, while the involvement of the TECNET Chairs Forum and Programme Managers ensures programmatic aspects are taken into account.  
  • External coordination with the European and Canadian space community is achieved via open consultation rounds four times per year. Note that topics are split into two cycles of up to 5 topics each (see below the topics and key dates for the ongoing cycles), and therefore two Mapping Consultations and two Roadmapping Consultations are held every year.

ESA Technology Harmonisation Advisory Group - THAG 

THAG is an ESA delegate body, established in 2006 to advise the ESA Industrial Policy Committee (IPC) on Technology Harmonisation matters, including:

  • Technology harmonisation work plans
  • Mapping of European capabilities with respect to the needs of the institutional and commercial markets
  • Implementation within ESA programmes of agreed roadmaps and conclusions, and identification of national-and European-level funding
  • Harmonisation measures to be applied in istitutional programmes and by industry

How to participate

The European Space Technology Harmonisation is a voluntary process, based on transparency and exchange of information. Continuous support from all participants is crucial to the success of this European initiative.

In case of interest in any of the topics addressed by the European Space Technology Harmonisation, the recommended approach is to seek involvement either through your national delegation (in the case of ESA Member and Associate States) or directly through ESA (harmo@esa.int). You will find the contact details of your national delegation in the European Space Technology Master Plan; the delegate may then recommend how to further proceed.

All European space sector stakeholders can access the Harmonisation Documents as well as the European Space Technology Master Plan via the Harmonisation Document Management System (HDMS: https://tec-polaris.esa.int --> eclipse). You may request an account to HDMS by sending an e-mail to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company.

Ongoing Harmonisation Cycles - topics and key dates

2024 Topics

Cycle 1  

Cycle 2

Cryogenics and Focal Plane Cooling  

Composite Materials

AOCS and GNC Systems  

Model Based for System Engineering

Electrochemical Energy Storage  

Electromagnetic Compatibility

Technologies for Passive Millimetre and Sub-Millimetre Wave Instruments  

Technologies for Fluid Mechanics

Technologies for Optical Passive Instruments – Stable & Lightweight Structures, Mirrors  

Cubesat Propulsion

2024 Meeting Dates

Cycle 1

Cycle 2

November-December 2023

Space Entities Mapping Consultation

February-March 2024

Space Entities Mapping Consultation

16-18 January 2024

Mapping Meeting

9-11 April 2024

Mapping Meeting

March-April 2024

Space Entities Roadmap Consultation

July-September 2024

Space Entities Roadmap Consultation

17-18 June 2024

Roadmap Meeting

27-28 November 2024

Roadmap Meeting

Harmonisation topics

Critical Active RF Technologies

Last harmonised in 2020. Candidate for revisit in 2025.

This topic is focused on Gallium Nitride (GaN) and Silicon (Si) technologies for active RF devices employed in RF blocks such as amplifiers, frequency converters and modulators. The role of GaN is fostered in RF power amplification up to the 100-GHz range, whereas Si technologies, in particular RF CMOS and BiCMOS, are increasingly substituting traditional GaAs for RF circuits in certain low-power functions such as routing, conditioning, signal generation and frequency synthesis up to Ka-band.

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Cryogenics and Focal Plane Cooling

Currently in Harmonisation. Publication expected late 2024.

Cryogenics in general is the domain of thermal science dedicated to the study and the production of temperature below 200K (according to ECSS-E-ST-31C definition). Applied to the Space Sector, this term describes the different types of technologies that permit to reach and maintain such temperatures. The following technologies are covered: 

- Radiators 

- Thermoelectric coolers 

- Cryostats 

 -Active cooling systems from 2K to 190K

  • Stirling cooler 
  • Pulse Tube cooler 
  • Joule Thomson expansion cooler 
  • Solid Sate cooling (e.g. laser-coolers) 
  • Reverse Turbo-Brayton cooler 
  • Microcooling 

- Sub-Kelvin cooler:

  • Adiabatic Demagnetisation Refrigerators (ADR) 
  • Dilution Refrigerator 
  • 3He-sorption pump cooler 

- Cooler drive electronics 

- Cryogenic System Equipment: equipment required to integrate the above mentioned cooling systems with the detectors and the Spacecraft 

- Cryogenic technologies for space transportation

  • Cryogenic insulation solutions 
  • Propellant management
  • Cold/Liquid Gas storage and transfer

- Cryogenics Heat Pipe and Loop Heat Pipes (for this one see the topic Heat Transport Equipment and Systems)

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Cubesat Propulsion

Currently in Harmonisation. Publication expected early 2025.

This topic addresses chemical, electric and advanced propulsion systems suitable for CubeSats of sizes up to 16U or 30kg of mass and capable of delivering thrust up to 0.5N. It covers:

- Chemical propulsion thrusters

  • Cold Gas
  • Mono-propellant
  • Bi-propellant 
  • Solid propellant
  • Hybrid propellant
  • Water electrolysis
  • Plasma Assisted Combustion, in connection with (or not) pyroelectrics

- Electric propulsion thrusters

  • Electrostatic: Electrospray thrusters, Field Emission Electric Propulsion, Gridded on Ion Engines, Hall Effect Thrusters, High Efficiency Multistage Plasma Thrusters
  • Electrothermal: Resistojet, Microwave Electrothermal Thrusters, Arcjets
  • Electromagnetic: Pulsed Plasma Thrusters, Vacuum Arc Thrusters, Helicon Plasma Thrusters including Ambipolar Thrusters, Electron Cyclotron Resonance Thrusters

- Other components: power and control electronics, power processing units, tanks, manifolds, feed systems, thruster pointing mechanisms, propulsion system modelling, test facilities, test diagnostics including thrust balances, propellants, GSE, pressure regulators, pressure transducers, mass flow sensors, mass flow controllers, temperature sensors, valves, filters, cathodes/neutralisers, harness and pipework.

Note that the coverage differs from that of Chemical Propulsion – Components (including Tanks) and Electric Propulsion Technologies principally in size, delivered thrust levels and approach adopted to qualification.

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

De-Orbiting Technologies

Last harmonised in 2023.

To limit the growth of space debris in an increasingly crowded space environment, new de-orbiting technologies and tools are required. These include technologies to passivate and dispose of the space segment, tools to model the reliability and compliance of such techniques, and solutions to ease the removal from orbit of spacecraft in case of failure. This topic covers technologies related to the areas listed below.

- De-orbit systems

  • Passive de-orbit systems (e.g. drag augmentation devices, tethers)
  • Active-de-orbit systems (controlled re-entry and semi-controlled re-entry)
  • Autonomous de-orbit systems

- Passivation (power, propulsion)

- Reliability of disposal systems for de-orbiting and passivation

- Design for Demise (e.g. tanks, reaction wheels, magnetometers, early break-up and containment technologies)

- Design for Removal (mechanical capture interface, detumbling technologies, markers, retroreflectors)

- System-level integration and validation

Note that this topic is closely related with ESA’s Zero Debris approach and ESA’s Clean Space office activities.

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Deployable Booms & Inflatable Structures

Last harmonised in 2018.

Deployable boom technology (consisting of booms and masts) is typically associated with deployable, elongated structural members, where the cross section is by far smaller than the deployed length. These kinds of structures are stowed for launch and then deployed to their operational configuration. This topic covers all various technologies of the booms and masts., including multiple degree of freedom articulated long booms. Inflatable structure technology covers support/deployment structures for satellite appendages (beams, tori, reflectors, etc.), inflatable reflectors/antennas and inflatable re-entry bodies, habitats, airbags and balloons.

- Deployable booms

  • Structural members
  • Joints
  • Synchronisation mechanisms

- Inflatable structures

  • Inflatable element
  • Inflation system
  • Rigidisation system
  • Launch containers

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Electric Propulsion Technologies

Last harmonised in 2022.

Electric Propulsion uses electricity to accelerate a propellant and produce thrust. This topic covers the technologies for use in space listed below.

- EP thrusters

  • Electrostatic: Electrospray Thrusters, Field Emission Electric Propulsion, Grided Ion Engines, Hall Effect Thrusters, High Efficiency Multistage Plasma Thrusters, Quad Confinement Thrusters
  • Electrothermal: Arcjets, Resistojets, Microwave Electrothermal Thrusters 
  • Electromagnetic: Pulsed Plasma Thrusters, Vacuum Arc Thrusters, Magneto Plasma Dynamic Thrusters, Helicon Plasma Thrusters, Electron Cyclotron Resonance Thrusters

- Cathodes/Neutralisers

- Power Processing Units

- Flow Control Units

- Radio Frequency Generators

- Filters and valves

- Pressure regulators 

- Pressure and temperature sensors

- Electric Propulsion Pointing Mechanisms

- Test facilities, Diagnostic Probes and Ground Support Equipment

- Thrust Balances

- Models and Codes

Note that Tanks are covered in Chemical Propulsion – Components (Tanks).

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Electrochemical Energy Storage

Currently in Harmonisation. Publication expected late 2024.

Energy Storage is a key part of almost every space mission, and is used to supply power during eclipse, to manage peak loads, and as a one-off (or contingency) source of electrical power.

Electrochemical energy storage is a subset of energy storage and it refers to technologies that store energy chemically to produce electrical power. 

  • Batteries: including primary batteries (non-rechargeable and thermal) and secondary, batteries (rechargeable)
  • Regenerative fuel cell systems: including H2/O2 fuel cells and electrolysers, solid oxide fuel cell, and Co/CO2 fuel cells
  • Supercapacitors: including Li ion capacitor

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Electromagnetic Compatibility

Currently in Harmonisation. Publication expected early 2025.

Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) refers to the ability of electronic devices and systems to function properly in their intended electromagnetic environment, without causing interference or being affected by interference from other devices or systems. EMC is not a technology as such, but in the context of harmonisation the EMC design, modelling and simulation tools, and test techniques are considered as technology.

- Design, modelling and simulation

  • Design for electromagnetic cleanliness and compatibility
  • Electromagnetic environment
  • EMC models and simulation tools

- Test techniques 

  • EMC test techniques 
  • Magnetic test methods, magnetic modelling and simulation 
  • Non-standard test methods for highly demanding requirements (approach for large infrastructure, e.g. habitat modules)

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Technologies for Fluid Mechanics

Currently in Harmonisation. Publication expected early 2025.

Fluid mechanics is the discipline that studies the flow of fluids: liquids and gases. Space applications are related to ascent, descent, landing, aerobraking, aerocapture, and aerogravity assist. This topic covers four main areas.

- Fluid dynamics tools and techniques

  • Classical Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools: Euler, Navier-Stokes and direct simulation Monte Carlo codes and associated grid generation tools
  • Advanced numerical methods: Large Eddy Simulation (LES) and Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) for high-fidelity simulation of smaller-scale turbulent structures
  • Physical models including thermochemistry, turbulence, transition, radiation, gas-surface interactions (oxidation, catalysis, ablation) and combustion
  • Design tools: analytical, fast parametric design tools, optionally coupled with trajectory analysis tools. Aerodynamic (ATD) database generation
  • Multi-disciplinary tools: informatic environment for coupling tools and databases of different technical disciplines; optimisation algorithms
  • Plume impingement: interaction between thruster plume and spacecraft or ground surfaces

- New capabilities and maintaining ground testing facilities used for general CFD validation; for database generation for design, and for flow phenomena research

  • Ideal Gas Facilities: classical subsonic, transonic, supersonic, and hypersonic wind tunnels and corresponding intrusive and nonintrusive measurements techniques
  • High Enthalpy Facilities: shock tubes, hot-shot wind tunnels, ballistic ranges
  • Plasma Facilities: arcjets and plasmatrons
  • Rocket Nozzle Test Stands: hot firings and jet interaction

- Sensors and measurements techniques: in-flight measurements (intrusive and non-intrusive) such as Air Data Systems, intelligent measurement systems, and miniaturisation of flight measurement techniques.

- Flight demonstrators and data analysis tools: flight and ground demonstration missions and experimental vehicles to study critical phenomena in ATD; exploitation of data from flight experiments, specially involving ATD and (re-)entry.

Note that from Harmonisation 2024 this topic will be extended to cover aspects of fluid mechanics hardware and renamed to “Technologies for Fluid Mechanics”.

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

Frequency and Time Generation and Distribution (Space & Ground)

Last harmonised in 2023.

Ultra-stable frequency and time sources play an important role in many modern applications, such as high-speed data transmission, time keeping, space navigation, and geodesy, and in supporting key elements of basic research in space. The areas covered by this topic include techniques and technologies for the generation, transfer and comparison of ultra-stable time/frequency signals, in both the RF/Microwave domain and in the optical domain (for dedicated payload without optical communications function).

- Time and Frequency generation: Space

  • On-board oscillators
  • Miniaturised atomic clocks
  • Atomic clocks and Clock Monitoring and Control Units
  • Microwave photonics

- Time and Frequency generation: Ground

  • Microwave clocks
  • Optical clocks and related technologies
  • Timescale generation

- Time and Frequency transfer and dissemination

- GNSS time and frequency transfer

- Two-Way Satellite Time and Frequency Transfer

- Optical fibre links

- Optical free-space links

For frequency and time distribution over physical or telemetry layer of free-space optical communications links please see Optical Communications for Space.

The Technology Harmonisation Dossier (THD) and Roadmap can be accessed via our Harmonisation Document Management System under the following links: THD LINK / Roadmap LINK  

If you do not have an account yet, you may request one by sending an email to harmo@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company. 

The European Space Technology Master Plan

ESA

The ESTMP sets out a European vision of technology for the coming years to support decisions of European stakeholders on space technology R&D.

The European Space Technology Master Plan (ESTMP), updated annually by ESA with all stakeholders, constitutes a comprehensive overview of technology R&D across Europe. In particular, it includes:

  • A snapshot of the space sector in the global context;
  • European institutional space technology R&D budgets;
  • An overview of the ESA technology R&D programmes updated to include new programmes stemming from the last Council at Ministerial;
  • An overview of technology programmes and initiatives by the European Commission and the European Defence Agency, including the Critical Space Technologies for Non-Dependence, jointly with ESA;
  • A presentation of ESA participating states, including organisation of national space technology R&D;
  • A list and description of the European Space Technology Harmonisation topics including Roadmap aims.

The most recent edition is the ESTMP 2023. For access to the publication contact us at estmp@esa.int from a corporate email address providing business affiliation and position in the company.